Climate Emergency: Researchers Find that PR Firms Have Spent Decades Fueling Climate Misinformation

by | Dec 1, 2021 | Climate & Environment, Politics & Corruption

Demonstrators at a Extinction Rebellion protest in Glasgow (Jane Barlow/PA) / PA Wire

Climate Emergency: Researchers Find that PR Firms Have Spent Decades Fueling Climate Misinformation

by | Dec 1, 2021 | Climate & Environment, Politics & Corruption

Demonstrators at a Extinction Rebellion protest in Glasgow (Jane Barlow/PA) / PA Wire
The best time for PR firms to stop working for fossil fuel clients was 20 years ago, when we had much more time to stop the climate emergency. The second best time is now.

Republished with permission from Common Dreams,  by Jessica Corbett

A pair of Brown University researchers on Tuesday exposed how public relations firms hired by the fossil fuel industry have significantly contributed to misinformation about the worsening climate emergency and impeded action to address it over the past few decades.

“The hard truth is that advertising and public relations agencies are essential to the fossil fuel industry’s propaganda machine.”

The new peer-reviewed paper, published in the journal Climatic Change, comes as Big Oil along with the advertising and PR firms they employ face mounting scrutiny within and beyond Congress—including at a historic U.S. House of Representatives hearing featuring fossil fuel CEOs last month.

Robert J. Brulle and Carter Werthman of the Institute at Brown for Environment and Society wrote that “as major players in the climate political arena,” PR firms such as Cerrell, Edelman, Glover Park, and Ogilvy “have shifted public discourse and the prospects for climate action.”

“The fossil fuel industry’s obstruction of climate action goes beyond misinformation and climate denial,” Brulle told DeSmog. “A major part of the effort to obstruct climate action involves enhancing the positive public reputation for the fossil fuel companies and emphasizing the benefits of continued fossil fuel use.”

“From the severity of climate impacts to policies to address the problem,” he said, “PR firms are a big part of the corporate propaganda machinery that guides the way Americans think about the issue.”

The researchers examined “the extent and nature of involvement” of more than 600 PR firms in climate-related political action by organizations in five sectors: coal, steel, and rail; oil and gas; utilities; renewable energy; and the environmental movement from 1988 to 2020.

“Within each sector, engagement of PR firms is concentrated in a few firms, and the major oil companies and electrical-supply manufactures are the heaviest employers of such firms,” the paper says, noting that the environmental movement engaged the fewest PR firms in the studied period.

“PR firms generally specialize in representing specific sectors, and a few larger PR firms are widely engaged in climate and energy political activity,” the paper continues. “PR firms developed campaigns that frequently relied on third-party groups to engage with the public, criticize opponents, and serve as the face of an advertising campaign.”

“The impact of these campaigns is hard to ascertain. However, these efforts have instantiated cultural concepts such as ‘coal country’ or ‘carbon footprint’ into the taken-for-granted discourse on climate change,” the study adds. Other terms that “originated with” and were “promulgated by” PR firms include “clean coal” and “renewable natural gas.”

Part of what makes this analysis notable is that—despite recent initiatives such as the Clean Creatives campaign—the public relations industry has faced limited scrutiny for its contributions to climate misinformation compared with major polluters and right-wing think tanks.

Brulle told The Washington Post‘s climate-focused newsletter that right-wing think tanks’ opposition to climate action has received far more attention from reporters and lawmakers.

“Everybody knows about the Heartland Institute and the Competitive Enterprise Institute and the Koch brothers. That’s not really news anymore,” Brulle said. “But the other 95% of these companies’ efforts to greenwash their reputations and shift public opinion are being ignored.”

That’s by design. The study points out that “the work of PR firms requires that they ‘remain invisible.’ Accordingly, PR firms and the organizations that engage their services have endeavored to maintain a low profile regarding their role in climate communications efforts.”

Duncan Meisel, director of Clean Creatives, which pressures ad and public relations agencies to drop fossil fuel clients, welcomed the researchers’ efforts to highlight the ties between fossil fuel companies and PR firms.

“Agencies like Edelman, Ogilvy, and WeberShandwick named in this report need to recognize that work for fossil fuel companies is doing significant damage to their reputation and legacy,” Meisel said. “The hard truth is that advertising and public relations agencies are essential to the fossil fuel industry’s propaganda machine, and work for fossil clients has stopped the world from adequately responding to the climate emergency.”

“The best time to stop working for fossil fuel clients was 20 years ago, when we had much more time to stop the climate emergency,” he added. “The second best time is now.”

<a href="http://commondreams.org" target="_blank">Common Dreams</a>

Common Dreams

Common Dreams has been providing breaking news & views for the progressive community since 1997. They are independent, non-profit, advertising-free and 100% reader supported.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Related Articles

Oct 05 2022

Voting Rights Are First Up on the Docket at the Supreme Court

Black voters make up more than a quarter of the Alabama’s population, but only one congressional district would be majority Black under the voting map drawn by...
Oct 04 2022

Can a New California Law Slow the “Plastics Pandemic?”

No one knows for sure how much plastic is in the world’s oceans, but in 2015 the best guess was 150 million metric tons, growing by eight to 11 million metric tons a...
Oct 04 2022

Big Pharma-Funded FDA Gets Drugs Out Faster, but at What Cost?

In 1992 Congress passed a law committing the drug industry to pay so-called user fees to help fund the FDA’s drug approval process. Big Pharma has used that law to...
Oct 03 2022

Babcock Ranch: A Case Study for Solar Power and Planning for the Worst

Not far from devastated Fort Meyers and Cape Coral, Babcock Ranch only had minor damage from Hurricane Ian and never lost power or internet access. The reasons for that...
Oct 01 2022

Chevron Admits It Is ‘Actively Murdering You’ in a Viral Parody Ad

Produced by Adam McKay, the director of “Don’t Look Up,” the ad assures viewers Chevron has “billions and billions of dollars to pay for this...
Sep 30 2022

The Practice of Gas Flaring Releases Five Times More Methane Than Previously Thought

A new study shows there is a lot more methane being added to the atmosphere than currently accounted for in any inventories or estimates. And the source is obvious and...
Sep 26 2022

The Koch Network Is Financing Election Deniers With Campaign Cash Ahead of Midterms

Charles Koch and his billionaire buddies in the Koch Network continue their pattern of trying to tear down our government by funding candidates who tried to turn our...
Sep 25 2022

How the Supreme Court Unleashed a Corporate Criminal Takeover of America

Because of key decisions by the Supreme Court equating money with free speech, our political system is now overrun with grifters, con artists and career...
Sep 22 2022

New York’s Lawsuit Against Donald Trump — A Tax Lawyer Explains What’s at Stake

While the New York Attorney General’s massive lawsuit against Donald Trump, his children and companies is a civil suit, it marks a beginning and an acceleration...
Sep 21 2022

How Privatization and Corruption Magnified Puerto Rico’s Vulnerability to Hurricanes

Still recovering from the 2017 disaster of Hurricane Maria, which killed 3000 Americans in Puerto Rico, the islands have been blacked again out by much smaller...
Subscribe for Updates!

Subscribe for Updates!

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from our team.

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This