Cement Production Creates More CO2 Than Aviation. Could Algae Help Solve This?

by | Sep 8, 2022 | Progress & Solutions

Concrete is responsible for more greenhouse gas emissions than aviation. Photo by Damjan Dobrila

Cement Production Creates More CO2 Than Aviation. Could Algae Help Solve This?

by | Sep 8, 2022 | Progress & Solutions

Concrete is responsible for more greenhouse gas emissions than aviation. Photo by Damjan Dobrila
Concrete production one of the most difficult industries to decarbonize. However, difficult does not necessarily mean impossible.

Humans produce more concrete than any other material on the planet. It is the literal foundation of modern civilization—and for good reason.

Concrete is strong, durable, affordable and available to almost every community on the planet. However, the global concrete industry has a dirty little secret—it alone is responsible for more than 8% of global carbon dioxide emissions—more than three times the emissions associated with aviation. Those emissions doubled in the past two decades as Asian cities grew, and demand is continuing to expand at an unprecedented rate.

It’s also one of the most difficult industries to decarbonize, in part because manufacturers are typically hyperlocal and operate on slim margins, leaving little to invest in technologies that could lower emissions.

However, difficult does not necessarily mean impossible.

Architects, engineers, scientists and cement and concrete manufacturers around the world are investigating and piloting several new strategies and technologies that can significantly reduce the carbon footprint of cement and concrete. Here are a few of them, including one my team at the University of Colorado is working on: figuring out ways to use all-natural microalgae to solve concrete’s biggest emissions problem—cement.

It Doesn’t Have to Be 100% Cement

The primary culprit behind concrete’s climate impact is the production of portland cement—the powder used to make concrete.

Cement is made by heating limestone rich in calcium carbonate to over 2,640 degrees Fahrenheit (1,450 Celsius). The calcium carbonate decomposes into calcium oxide, or quicklime, and carbon dioxide—a climate-warming greenhouse gas. This chemical reaction, what the Portland Cement Association calls a “chemical fact of life,” is responsible for a whopping 60% or so of cement-related emissions. The remainder comes from energy to heat the kiln.

One of the most promising short-term strategies for reducing concrete’s carbon footprint uses materials like fly ash from coal plants, slag from iron production, and calcined clay to replace some of the portland cement in concrete mixtures. These are known as supplementary cementitious materials.

Using 20% to 50% fly ash, slag or calcined clay can reduce the embodied carbon of concrete mixtures by about the same percentages.

Another method uses small amounts of ground limestone to replace some of the cement and is becoming a best practice. After rigorous testing, the California Department of Transportation recently announced it would allow portland-limestone cement mixes, known as PLC, in its projects. With 5% to 15% ground limestone replacing cement, PLC can reduce emissions by about the same amount. California’s decision quickly led other states to approve the use of PLC.

Many researchers are now advocating for the adoption of limestone calcined-clay cement, which contains about 55% portland cement, 15% ground limestone and 30% calcined clay. It could cut emissions by more than 45%.

What Electrification and Carbon Capture Can Do

Cement plants have also started testing carbon capture technologies and electric kilns to slash emissions. But carbon capture is expensive, and scaling the technology to meet the demand of the cement and concrete industry is no easy feat.

Kiln electrification faces the same barriers. New technologies and large capital investments are required to electrify one of the world’s most energy-intensive processes. However, the promise of zero combustion-related emissions is enticing enough for some entrepreneurs and cement companies—including those interested in using 100% solar energy for cement production—who are racing to find solutions that are both technologically and economically viable at scale.

The Inflation Reduction Act, which Congress passed in August 2022, could help put some of these technologies to wider use. It includes funding for modernizing equipment and adding carbon capture capabilities, as well as tax credit incentives for manufacturers to cut their emissions.

Going Cement-Free, Possibly With Algae

Another strategy is to produce functionally equivalent materials that contain no portland cement whatsoever.

Materials like alkali-activated slag or fly ash cement concrete are produced by combining slag, fly ash or both with a very strong base. These materials have been shown to cut carbon emissions by 90% or more, and they might meet scale and cost criteria, but they still face technical and regulatory challenges.

Some examples of low-carbon, portland cement-free concrete products that have gained market traction include wollastonite-based modular components, compressed earth blocks and prefabricated biocement products—including those produced using photosynthetic, biomineralizing microalgae.

Algae have also been used as an alternative biofuel for heating cement kilns, and algae cultivation systems have also been linked with cement production to capture carbon.

My team at the University of Colorado Boulder and I are looking into the use of algae-derived limestone for portland cement production, which could help eliminate 60% of the emissions associated with cement manufacturing. This technology is appealing because it is plug-and-play with conventional cement production.

Using Concrete to Lock Captured CO2 Away

Engineers are also experimenting with injecting captured carbon dioxide into concrete as well as using aggregates made of carbon dioxide in place of gravel or sand that is mixed into concrete.

It’s an exciting concept, but so far injection has yielded limited carbon dioxide reductions, and production of carbon-dioxide-storing aggregates has yet to scale up.

A Growing Problem

Ultimately, time will tell whether these and other technologies will live up to their promise.

What is certain is that there has been a worldwide reckoning within the cement and concrete industry that it has a problem to solve and no silver bullet solution. It may take a suite of solutions tailored to both local and global markets to address the immediate and long-term challenges of keeping up with an ever-growing population and rapidly changing climate.The Conversation

Republished with permission from The Conversation, by Wil Srubar, Assistant Professor of Architectural Engineering and Materials Science, University of Colorado Boulder

 
The Conversation

The Conversation

The Conversation is a nonprofit, independent news organization dedicated to unlocking the knowledge of experts for the public good. We publish trustworthy and informative articles written by academic experts for the general public and edited by our team of journalists.

Comments

Follow Us

Related Articles

Jan 23 2023

Car-Sharing Services Turn to Electric Cars and Nonprofit Business Models

Car-share operations are turning to electric vehicles as they reimagine the service as an affordable, nonprofit transportation business model.
Jan 03 2023

New Tools Take a Crack at Predicting Healthcare Costs

This year healthcare providers will be required to provide predictions of costs finally giving patients more freedom to comparison-shop and possibly help slow rising...
Jan 03 2023

US Wind and Solar Are Projected to Outpace Coal and Nuclear in 2023

It is entirely possible that the combination of just wind and solar will outpace nuclear power and maybe even that of coal during the next twelve months.
Dec 17 2022

Petition Pressures US House Members Not to Seat GOP Insurrectionists in 2023

The petition argues that Republican Reps. like Paul Gosar, Lauren Boebert, and Marjorie Taylor Greene “are ineligible to hold future public office” under...
Dec 14 2022

Electoral Count Reform Act: Congress Prepares to Prevent Presidential Election Mischief and Fraud

A bipartisan group of congressional leaders aims to pass reforms to the 1887 law governing Presidential elections, the Electoral Count Act, before the end of...
Dec 09 2022

Five Companies Win Leases for Floating Wind Turbines Off California: How Do They Work?

Some of our strongest wind resources are well away from shore in locations with hundreds of feet of water below, so it makes good sense to deploy floating wind turbines...
Dec 07 2022

Raphael Warnock Wins Georgia’s U.S. Senate Runoff, Giving Democrats a 51-Seat Majority

Warnock enjoyed a significant lead among early voters, and while Walker’s tally crept up throughout Tuesday night thanks to Election Day voters, he failed to overcome...
Nov 27 2022

DOJ Opens Investigation Into Rent-Setting Tech Company RealPage

The DOJ will examine whether RealPage helped landlords coordinate rent increases. Questions also swirl around a 2017 merger deal with its largest competitor.
Nov 17 2022

Farmers in the Midwest Are Turning to Solar to Boost Profits

As adoption of solar projects on farmland climbs, many farmers and industry players are looking for ways to add solar to agricultural production without halting crop...
Nov 15 2022

Cultivating Human Farming Practices and Wisdom From Ants

Agricultural pest management has focused on genetically engineering crops to produce their own pesticides, but the lesson from 55 million years of ant agriculture is to...
Subscribe for Updates!

Subscribe for Updates!

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from our team.

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This