How the Religious Right Made Cruelty Sacred

by | Sep 25, 2022 | Opinions & Commentary

Photo by Levi Meir Clancy

How the Religious Right Made Cruelty Sacred

by | Sep 25, 2022 | Opinions & Commentary

Photo by Levi Meir Clancy
Supposed followers of the same Jesus whose family fled to Egypt to avoid genocide, are actually celebrating malicious political stunts and branding our condemnation of them as partisan politics.

Well, they’ve finally done it.

The Religious Right has completed their wholesale reboot of Christianity and it now bears no resemblance to the original. It has fully abandoned its namesake.

This week, watching Republican governors shipping exhausted migrants to other areas of the country in brazen acts of performative cruelty has been horrifying—but not nearly as much as witnessing the theological and mental gymnastics so many professed Christians have engaged in while trying to justify traumatizing already traumatized people.

It has been a grievous thing to see human beings who openly wield their adoration of Jesus, miss the stratospheric irony of their intentional mistreatment of those he claimed such affinity for while he was here: their heartless, loveless response to those he called “the least of these,” in the way the world disregarded and injured them. They find all of this perfectly fine, even Christian.

Supposed followers of the same Jesus whose family fled to Egypt to avoid genocide, are actually celebrating these malicious political stunts and branding our condemnation of them, partisan politics. That is how far afield they have drifted in 2,000 years.

Republican Christians have so lost the plot, that affirming anything remotely compassionate or decent now feels to them like a political attack; so fully embraced a Christianity of cruelty that actual empathy seems an act of defiant resistance to them.

In many ways, it now is.

  • Advocating for sanctuary for refugees,
  • Protecting immigrants from Government harassment,
  • Demanding full equality for women,
  • Insisting on affordable healthcare for every human being,
  • Opposing the proliferation of assault weapons,
  • Affirming religious freedom for all traditions,
  • Fighting the degradation of our planet and the gutting of our public schools,
  • Defending our Press so that it remains free,
  • Championing the vulnerable, the sick, the poor—these have somehow become partisan politics and assaults on their religious freedom.

And the simple reason, is because the leaders of the Republican party and the Evangelical ministers in bed with them, no longer care to be burdened by the expansive heart of Jesus, the basic goodness he preached, the people he poured out his life for.

  • And so his values now seem offensive to them,
  • his words are convicting,
  • his very life feels confrontational.
  • The extravagant love, overflowing compassion, and sacrificial generosity that marked him are foreign to their ears and threatening to their sensibilities.
  • And these things all have no home in their religion.

The very idea that coming to the aid of refugees and migrants now feels like culture war salvos to Republicans, instead of the beautiful defense of the inherent value of all people that it is—should be a red flag to people who are paying attention. It should be an alarm, warning them that things have gone sideways—especially to those folks who claim faith.

If speaking the very words of Jesus, if reiterating his compassion and generosity seem like partisan politics to those of you reading this who identify as Republicans—well maybe that’s a problem. If someone aspiring to be a loving, empathetic human being causes you discomfort—that should give you great pause.

Maybe the truth is that equality, diversity, justice, and compassion are indeed now solely “Democratic talking points” because you have gone all-in with something that Jesus would rightly be horrified by.
Maybe you really no longer aspire to loving your neighbor as yourself as much as you imagine or profess to.Maybe your expression of faith is lacking something essential.

Perhaps the absence of gentleness and mercy in your midst have left him no choice but to head elsewhere, joining the religious of every tradition and the non-religious who together are affirming these things.

I wonder where Conservative Christians see the Jesus in shipping beleaguered migrants to Blue areas of this country; how they can celebrate with joyous middle finger defiance using human beings as some sort of prop in political posturing.

I have seen Jesus in the response of those on the ground in Martha’s Vineyard, as disparate human beings there, some claiming faith and some not—understand that empathy is the only redemptive path worth taking and have appealed to their better angels.

So yes, my dear Republican Christian friends, maybe homeless refugees and sick children and the working poor and black lives and fewer guns and universal healthcare are indeed now “Democratic talking points”. And if they are, then you should take a long look in the mirror, let your knees hit the floor, and ask Jesus just why that is. Maybe some repentance is in order.

As for me: I know where my heart is, I know where my loyalties lay, and I know that I can sleep at night because I know that love is a nonpartisan decision and I am choosing it.

Republished with permission from John Pavlovitz.
John Pavlovitz

John Pavlovitz

John Pavlovitz is a writer, pastor, and activist from Wake Forest, North Carolina. A 25-year veteran in the trenches of local church ministry, John is committed to equality, diversity, and justice—both inside and outside faith communities. When not actively working for a more compassionate planet, John enjoys spending time with his family, exercising, cooking, and having time in nature. He is the author of A Bigger Table, Hope and Other Superpowers, Low, and Stuff That Needs to Be Said.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Follow Us

Related Articles

Feb 02 2023

The Ambition of Ron DeSantis: Big Brother, Fahrenheit 451 or Both?

Ron DeSantis has pushed for a curriculum that whitewashes—irony intended—the vast history of oppression of black members of American society throughout our...
Feb 01 2023

A Reality Check on the GOP Promise to Balance the Federal Budget

A quick look back at how we briefly balanced the budget twenty years ago, along with how much has changed, shows that Republicans are unlikely to manage a similar...
Jan 30 2023

Yes, White Supremacy Killed Tyre Nichols

When black officers pulled Tyre Nichols over, they did so as representatives of a faulty apparatus, one that has for decades perpetuated the message that black people...
Jan 28 2023

Old-Timey Yellow Journalism Is Alive and Well at FOX “News”

We generally think of yellow journalism as a revenue driver, with click bait titles, loosely-researched or fully fabricated facts presented as gospel. But the same...
Jan 27 2023

Trump’s Return to Facebook and Twitter Might Be More His Problem Than Ours

Perhaps the more important fact about Trump’s anticipated return to Twitter and Facebook is that he now owns a competing social media platform. The implications...
Jan 22 2023

A Review of Today’s Republican Party: Bring in the Malignant Clowns

The Republican Party’s dubious hallmark is willed stupidity super-glued to shameless hypocrisy: They want to cut a bedrock social programs despite the fact that...
Jan 20 2023

An Open Letter to the Department of Justice: Act Now to Remove Insurrectionists from Congress

The very ability of our government to function on our behalf is being held hostage by insurrectionists in Congress and the ransom is unacceptable. Where is the...
Jan 15 2023

Transfer of Power: The Constitutional Crisis of 1801

As a country, we don’t remember what happened 222 years ago, because we tend not to remember history. But also because that political storm “rolled harmlessly away.”...
Jan 09 2023

Far-Right Fundraising and the Empty Threats of the Treason Caucus

The far-right members of the lower house may have been running a sort of “professional wrestling” operation by holding up McCarthy’s possession of...
Jan 05 2023

The Speaker of the House Impasse: A Call for Six Republicans to Grow a Pair and Step Up

Surely there are six Republicans that can grow a pair and stand up for their oath of office and put the House of Representatives back into operation.
Subscribe for Updates!

Subscribe for Updates!

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from our team.

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This