Most Slave Plantation Tours Omit the Horrors of Slavery

by | Dec 8, 2021 | Racism (Us vs Them), Human Rights

These statues of enslaved young boys are part of a modern-day depiction of southern plantation life at the Whitney Museum in Louisiana. AP Photo/Gerald Herbert

Most Slave Plantation Tours Omit the Horrors of Slavery

by | Dec 8, 2021 | Racism (Us vs Them), Human Rights

These statues of enslaved young boys are part of a modern-day depiction of southern plantation life at the Whitney Museum in Louisiana. AP Photo/Gerald Herbert
Even now, discussions during plantation tours among visitors can often turn into visceral debates over whether the history of slavery should be told or ignored.

Republished with permission from The Conversation, by Kelley Fanto Deetz, University of California, Berkeley

Located on nearly 2,000 acres along the banks of the Potomac River, Stratford Hall Plantation is the birthplace of Confederate Gen. Robert E. Lee and the home of four generations of the Lee family, including two signers of the Declaration of Independence, Richard Henry Lee and Francis Lightfoot Lee.

It was also the home of hundreds of enslaved Africans and African Americans. From sunup to sundown, they worked in the fields and in the Great House. Until fairly recently, the stories of these enslaved Africans and of their brothers and sisters toiling at plantations across the Southern U.S. were absent from any discussions during modern-day tours of plantations such as Stratford Hall.

Even now, with new tours and an exhibition highlighting enslaved Africans and African Americans who lived at Stratford Hall, discussions during plantation tours among visitors can often turn into visceral debates over whose history should be told or ignored.

These tensions are part of an ever-growing work of criticism directed at sites that continue to omit the history of the enslaved community. Of the 600 plantations scattered throughout the South, only one, the Whitney Plantation in Louisiana, focuses entirely on the experiences of the enslaved.

As a public historian and the director of collections and visitor engagement at Stratford Hall, I can attest that visitors have vastly different expectations when they visit this historic landmark. Their questions reflect their own interpretations, curiosities and political biases, often to the detriment of obtaining a richer education on every aspect of plantation life — the good, the bad and the ugly.

Awkward Questions

Museum professionals at plantations hear it all and must balance viewpoints that are diametrically opposed to one another, such as the romanticized notion of antebellum gentility and the constant fear of terror and violence of the enslaved. Visitors’ expectations often collide with reality, creating tense moments on tours. Some visitors want answers and stories that sit comfortably with their ideas of slavery and of America as a whole.

“Were the Lees good slave owners?” is a frequent question.

A view of Stratford Hall Plantation in Virginia, birthplace of Gen. Robert E. Lee, circa 1950. Photo by Authenticated News/Archive Photos/Getty Images

Many visitors comment on how the slaves were treated like family, or how their housing doesn’t seem that bad. Some would rather skip the whole slavery thing altogether and just comfortably learn about the decorative arts and the often luxurious lives of the white families who lived there.

But history is not comfortable. Though he lived at Stratford Hall only during his early years, Robert E. Lee was a slave owner in his own right. The majority of the nearly 200 enslaved people Gen. Lee owned were inherited after his father-in-law, George Washington Parke Custis, died in 1857.

For every question about the kindness of the enslavers are others seeking detailed descriptions of abuse and terror.

“How much abuse happened here?” is one such question.

The answer is clear about the innate inhumanity of slavery. Abuse ran rampant, everything from rape and dismemberment to separating families. Enslaved people lived in constant fear. Violence was always a threat, in one form or another.

These questions plague many historic sites. Museum professionals are then saddled with spending more time explaining the lack of specific evidence of abuse on their site—or examples in their records—and spending less time talking about the ways enslaved men, women and children used their culture and community to persevere in a system built on violence and terror.

Violence was not all enslaved people experienced on plantations. Questions that focus heavily on the treatment of the enslaved—and not the people themselves—erase their humanity and ignore their agency.

Enslaved people on South Carolina plantation in 1862. Slavery Images: A Visual Record of the African Slave Trade and Slave Life in the Early African Diaspora

It also reduces their entire existence into a byproduct of white behavior and, worse, diminishes their cultures and their contributions to both the site and the nation as a whole.

Tour guides are pivotal in providing richer, more inclusive educational experiences. Yet we regularly endure personal attacks and offensive commentary. Historical interpreter Dontavius Williams works around the country at plantation sites, and, despite his authoritative expertise, Williams, 38, has told me and others in the field that he has been called “boy” on several occasions.

Many African American interpreters also have to address statements about how slavery was good for their ancestors.

Inclusion Is Not Exclusion

The visitors’ role is to learn from the staff and engage in ways that generate constructive conversations. Facilitators like Williams are trained in encouraging such talks, regardless of the visitors’ preconceived notions, political agendas or fixed notions about slavery and other confirmation biases.

What brings a more nuanced and balanced tour are questions about who made the furniture, who cooked the food, what people ate, how enslaved people persevered in spite of enslavement or which West African traditions survived in the Colonies.

This inclusion does not equate to exclusion. Visitors can learn of the white family, the decorative arts—and the enslaved community.

Historic sites are not Disneyland, U.S. history is not fantasy and plantations are inherently uncomfortable places. If tourists ask the deeper, more nuanced questions, they will get answers that challenge preconceived ideas and render a more complete understanding of our nation’s history.The Conversation

The Conversation

The Conversation

The Conversation is a nonprofit, independent news organization dedicated to unlocking the knowledge of experts for the public good. We publish trustworthy and informative articles written by academic experts for the general public and edited by our team of journalists.

1 Comment

  1. RN

    You note that ” ‘How much abuse happened here?’ is one such question.
    The answer is clear about the innate inhumanity of slavery. Abuse ran rampant, everything from rape and dismemberment to separating families. Enslaved people lived in constant fear. Violence was always a threat, in one form or another.”

    The implication is that the rape, dismemberment, separation of families, etc., are the factors proving that slaves were abused. In fact, even had those people been treated lovingly, fed well, kept intact with their families, given respect and financial recompense, the fact is that they were PROPERTY. This alone is a horrific abuse.

    It’s heartening to see the facts surfacing about the abominations perpetuated upon an entire culture and community in our country’s history. Not until we are honest about our sins can we begin to make things right.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles

police car at street
Jan 20 2022

Wait, There’s More — Now Republicans Want an Election Police Force

Both former gubernatorial candidate David Perdue and Florida Governor DeSantis are proposing an election police force to bolster the Big Lie from Trump that the 2020...
Jan 16 2022

Trump Continues to Tell Us What He Is: A Racist

In the four years Trump spent in the White House, he set back progress against racism and white supremacy decades. And he wants to keep this degradation of American...
Jan 07 2022

Reality Check: Fascism and the Return of the Book Burners

Fascism has a playbook, handed down from generations of dictators, all who ascended to power using this easy-to-follow checklist. Part of that checklist is doing away...
Jan 06 2022

History Tells Us That January 6th Will Be Repeated and It Is on Each of Us to Prevent That From Happening

Comparing the January 6th insurrection with Hitler’s failed coup of 1923 is appropriate. And it is a warning that those who tried to overthrow our government are...
Jan 04 2022

Records Show Facebook Hosted a Surge of Misinformation and Insurrection Threats Prior to Jan. 6 Attack

A ProPublica/Washington Post analysis of Facebook posts, internal company documents and interviews, provides the clearest evidence yet that the social media giant...
Jan 03 2022

Racial Discrimination in Farm Policies Is Destroying Black Farms

Blatant racial discrimination has driven hundreds of thousands of good, Black farmers off the land.
A young African American woman casting her ballot in 1964
Jan 01 2022

Priority List for 2022: Voting Rights, Voting Rights and Voting Rights

The former guy complained that expanding voting rights would set a stage where “Republicans could never get elected again.” Frankly, since the Republican...
Dec 31 2021

Is Anti-Vax Messaging Actually Driving “Healthcare” Profits?

Anti-vax hysteria obscures the fact that a vast river of money is being spent on hospitalization of those who bought into anti-vax messaging.
Dec 30 2021

Nazis, White Supremacy and the Dark Heart of Hatred

Intellectuals and intelligent people in general are capable of rapidly recognizing bullshit when they see it. So it is easy to see why the leaders of ineffectuals hate...
Dec 28 2021

Remembrance of a Giant: Desmond Tutu, 1931 – 2021

Desmond Tutu didn’t just get us to march against something. He got us to march for something, for a better day, for a better world. Tutu “said no” to injustice, and—the...
Subscribe for Updates!

Subscribe for Updates!

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from our team.

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This