The Onion Goes to Bat at the Supreme Court With Both Humor and Masterful Legal Points

by | Oct 5, 2022 | Human Rights & Justice

The Onion's Facebook masthead.

The Onion Goes to Bat at the Supreme Court With Both Humor and Masterful Legal Points

by | Oct 5, 2022 | Human Rights & Justice

The Onion's Facebook masthead.
The Onion's amicus brief to the Supreme Court is a triple threat: masterfully written, draws attention to an important case that could easily skate by unnoticed, and nails the argument.

The satirical newspaper The Onion on Monday filed an amicus brief mixing humor with legal arguments in support of an Ohio man who was briefly jailed over a parody Facebook page mocking his local police department.

The filing says The Onion—”the world’s leading news publication”—submitted the brief “to protect its continued ability to create fiction that may ultimately merge into reality. As the globe’s premier parodists, The Onion‘s writers also have a self-serving interest in preventing political authorities from imprisoning humorists.”

In 2016, police in Parma, Ohio arrested and jailed Anthony Novak after he created a Facebook page resembling the local police department’s own page on the social network.

According to the Associated Press, Novak’s posts included a hiring announcement “strongly encouraging minorities to not apply” and a fake event where any convicted pedophile could be “removed from the sex offender registry and accepted as an honorary police officer.”

Novak was charged with one felony count of disrupting public services but was acquitted at trial. He subsequently sued, alleging violations of his constitutional rights. However, the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals dismissed Novak’s suit by granting Parma police officers qualified immunity, a legal doctrine broadly shielding cops and other government officials from civil lawsuits.

“Americans can be put in jail for poking fun at the government? This was a surprise to America’s Finest News Source and an uncomfortable learning experience for its editorial team,” the brief states. “Indeed, ‘Ohio Police Officers Arrest, Prosecute Man Who Made Fun of Them on Facebook’ might sound like a headline ripped from the front pages of The Onion—albeit one that’s considerably less amusing because its subjects are real.”

“The 6th Circuit’s ruling imperils an ancient form of discourse,” the brief asserts. “The court’s decision suggests that parodists are in the clear only if they pop the balloon in advance by warning their audience that their parody is not true.”

“But some forms of comedy don’t work unless the comedian is able to tell the joke with a straight face,” the document continues. “Parody is the quintessential example. Parodists intentionally inhabit the rhetorical form of their target in order to exaggerate or implode it—and by doing so demonstrate the target’s illogic or absurdity.”

The brief argues:

  • Parody functions by tricking people into thinking that it’s real;
  • Because parody mimics the “real thing,” it has the unique capacity to criticize the real thing;
  • A reasonable reader does not need a disclaimer to know that parody is parody; and
  • It should be obvious that parodists cannot be prosecuted for telling a joke with a straight face.

The Onion cannot stand idly by in the face of a ruling that threatens to disembowel a form of rhetoric that has existed for millennia, that is particularly potent in the realm of political debate, and that, purely incidentally, forms the basis of The Onion‘s writers’ paychecks,” the filing asserts.

The Onion intends to continue its socially valuable role bringing the disinfectant of sunlight into the halls of power,” the brief adds. “And it would vastly prefer that sunlight not to be measured out to its writers in 15-minute increments in an exercise yard.”

Republished with permission from Common Dreams, by Brett Wilkins
<a href="" target="_blank">Common Dreams</a>

Common Dreams

Common Dreams has been providing breaking news & views for the progressive community since 1997. They are independent, non-profit, advertising-free and 100% reader supported.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Follow Us

Related Articles

Dec 01 2022

Ron DeSantis Puts Academics Under Attack in the Name of “Freedom”

A specialty of the so-called “champions of freedom” is to prohibit everything that does not suit their interests. Their repeated “free speech” means...
Nov 30 2022

Oath Keepers Convictions, the Limits of Free Speech — And the Threat Posed By Militias

Far-right extremists or other hate groups can claim they are just venting or even fantasizing—both of which would be protected under the First Amendment. For this...
Nov 23 2022

The Supreme Court Denies Trump’s Final Bid to Hide Tax Returns From House Committee

The ridiculous and repeated delaying tactics by Trump to hide his tax returns from Congress are finally over.
Nov 20 2022

Profits Over People: The Danger of Private Equity’s Stealthy Takeover of Health Care

Private equity is rapidly moving to reshape health care in America, coming off a banner year in 2021, when the deep-pocketed firms plowed $206 billion into more than...
Nov 18 2022

First Amendment: Censorship Law Backed by DeSantis Struck Down by Federal Judge

A Federal judge ruled, “…the First Amendment does not permit the State of Florida to muzzle its university professors, impose its own orthodoxy of...
Nov 11 2022

The Lost and Nearly Forgotten Story of the Bonus Army March

The Bonus Army March was one of the few times in American history when the U.S. military was used to shut down a massive demonstration of peaceful protesters.
Nov 03 2022

On Election Day—What to Do if Your Vote Is Challenged

Voting on election day is your right, privilege and duty. With all the noise created by the former president, complexities have been generated that can get in your way....
Nov 02 2022

The Barbaric Results of Republican Abortion Bans

In a new Senate report healthcare providers explained how abortion bans have adversely affected their ability to care for patients and have cut down on abortion access...
Oct 28 2022

Michigan Abortion Rights Vote: A Collision and Medicine and Politics

Kansas voted this year to keep abortion legal. Now Michigan is one of five states asking voters to weigh in on abortion policy in the wake of the Supreme Court’s June...
Oct 24 2022

Meet the Major Corporations Bankrolling the Anti-Abortion Attorneys General Group

Major corporations are backing RAGA (Republican Attorney Generals Association) which is devoting resources to key attorneys general races across the country.
Subscribe for Updates!

Subscribe for Updates!

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from our team.

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This