The Supreme Court’s Overturn of Roe v. Wade Turns Back the Clock on Democracy Itself

by | Jun 25, 2022 | Opinions, Human Rights & Justice

"My Right My Decision" rally United States Supreme Court Photo: Salud Carbajal, Wiki Commons

The Supreme Court’s Overturn of Roe v. Wade Turns Back the Clock on Democracy Itself

by | Jun 25, 2022 | Opinions, Human Rights & Justice

"My Right My Decision" rally United States Supreme Court Photo: Salud Carbajal, Wiki Commons
It’s not a ‘democracy’ when minority-elected presidents nominate Supreme Court justices who overturn constitutional protections and give state governments the power to do more of the same.

Many Americans may find it increasingly difficult to convince their international peers that the U.S. is truly a representative democracy.

A president who lost the popular vote (twice) nominated three conservative Supreme Court justices. Another president who lost the popular vote in his first term nominated two.

Now, these justices have overturned Roe v. Wade, despite Roe enjoying the support of 70% of Americans, according to the Pew Research Center.

But Justice Alito’s opinion makes no claim that conservative justices are trying to appease the American majority. Rather, his draft claims that overturning Roe will be more democratic, that doing so will empower states to decide abortion law for themselves.

But can state governments be trusted to play fair?

State Governments Are Disinterested in Representing Their Constituents

Of the 26 states set to outlaw or severely restrict abortion access now that Roe v. Wade is overturned, Pew reports that the states where a majority or plurality of residents want abortion to remain legal are as follows:

  • Arizona: 49% pro-choice vs. 46% anti-choice
  • Florida: 56% vs. 39%
  • Iowa: 52% vs. 46%
  • Michigan: 54%  vs. 42%
  • Montana: 56% vs. 38%
  • Nebraska: 50% vs. 46%
  • Ohio: 48% vs. 47%
  • Oklahoma: 51% vs. 45%
  • Wisconsin: 53% vs. 45%

One-third of the state governments set to severely restrict or ban abortion represent populations where more residents want abortion to remain legal than don’t.

These nine state governments (who represent a combined population of some 67.6 million Americans) are failing their constituents. By their own actions, they’re making the case for why crucial human rights like a woman’s right to choose an abortion must remain under Constitutional protection.

Beyond the unwillingness of state governments to accurately represent their constituents, there’s a history lesson to remind us why abortion rights are for all women of a free nation, not just some of them.

As one historian put it, “Issues of individual rights bearing such heavy moral weight (as abortion) cannot be contained within state boundaries. ‘Let’s leave it up to the states’ will quickly become: ‘We expect other states to comply with our laws and will demand federal action to guarantee it.’”

That historian is drawing a lesson from the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850, which aimed to mollify southern states in their growing frustration that northern states refused to cooperate with the South’s slave laws.

The Act provided the legal framework for slave-holding states to demand that free states in the North return runaway slaves.

Back then, the existence of slavery anywhere meant the protection of it everywhere.

How long before similar conflicts arise around abortion access? Missouri legislators have already proposed a law that would allow private citizens to sue anyone who helps a Missouri resident have an abortion, even if that aid was provided outside Missouri’s borders.

From the person who drives a Missouri woman to an out-of-state abortion clinic to the doctor at that clinic, no one would be safe from Missouri legislators’ wild notion that their laws apply not just in Missouri, but in every state Missouri residents travel to.

Beyond the moral hypocrisy of Missouri state legislators (who proclaim to respect states’ rights) trying to enforce their laws on residents of other states, their proposal bears painful resemblance to the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850.

And while many Americans might not recall the Slave Act and the political, ideological, and often bloody fallout it created, every American certainly knows what happened 11 years later when the South felt it could no longer use political action alone to force its slave society upon the rest of the nation.

Alito’s Opinion Drives Us Further From a Resolution

Federalism, our chosen form of government in which some powers are held federally and some by the states, is a robust system that allows states to function as partially independent units.

This system works (more or less), but it only works when the republic guarantees basic rights to all citizens.

To allow broadly unaccountable institutions on the state and judicial level to impose severe limitations on what human rights are respected in which states is not only highly undemocratic, it flirts with a return to the same kind of state-to-state infighting and ideological bloodletting that brought the nation to its knees in 1861.

This is not a road we wish to travel again.

Republished with permission from the author. First published in the Tennessean.

Ren Brabenec

Ren Brabenec

Ren Brabenec is a writer, activist, and Planned Parenthood volunteer residing in Nashville, Tennessee.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Related Articles

Aug 15 2022

Georgia Book-Banning Mothers Claim Their First Amendment Rights Are Being Violated

The self-dubbed Mama Bears filed a federal lawsuit alleging that by not being allowed to read sexually explicit material aloud at school board meetings, they themselves...
man in black sweatpants using DEWALT circular saw and cutting a wood plank
Aug 14 2022

The Job Numbers: What’s Missing Is Data About What They Are and What They Pay

The economy keeps adding jobs by the hundreds of thousands. But those big numbers don’t tell the whole story. If you need two or three to make ends meet, the big...
People attend an event of reading pro-democracy manifestos, outside the Faculty of Law headquarters at the Sao Paulo University, in downtown Sao Paulo, Brazil August 11, 2022. REUTERS/Amanda Perobelli
Aug 12 2022

Massive Pro-Democracy Protests Sweep Brazil

Presidential candidates spoke out in defense of Brazil’s electronic voting system, which has been the target of baseless allegations of fraud by Bolsonaro and his...
A Texas law says slavery cannot be taught as part of the ‘true founding’ of the United States. Tamir Kalifa/Getty Images
Aug 12 2022

Conservative Politicians Seek to Revise History Lessons About Slavery in the United States

A Texas proposal to “redefine” slavery grew out of work done under a Texas law that says slavery and racism can’t be taught as part of the “true founding”...
A patient is brought to tears as a staff member informs her that a San Antonio, Texas clinic can no longer provide abortion services after moments earlier the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade on June 24, 2022. (Photo: Gina Ferazzi/Los Angeles Times via Getty Images)
Aug 11 2022

Senator Warren Opens Investigation Into Damaging Impacts of GOP Abortion Bans

Reports of people facing severe health crises after being rejected for basic healthcare services and medications due to GOP abortion bans are “a harbinger of the...
Aug 11 2022

Are We Finally Seeing the “End of Days” for Trump?

As legal experts have indicated, Trump is scared. He’s been caught and knows it. He was provided with an inventory of what the FBI took in their search at...
The gate to former President Donald Trump’s home at Mar-A-Lago in Palm Beach, Fla., on Aug. 8, 2022. Photo by Eva Marie Uzcategui/Getty Images
Aug 10 2022

How Did the FBI Know What to Search for at Mar-A-Lago?

We might get some hints of what the FBI found at Mar-a-Lago if Trump does get indicted for a crime related to removing the documents or based on something found in...
Marcus and Allyson Ward of Chicago moved across the country to be closer to family after the premature birth of their twins, Milo and Theo, left them with about $80,000 in medical debt. (Taylor Glascock for KHN and NPR)
Aug 09 2022

100 Million Americans Are Saddled With Medical Debt

Investigation reveals that medical debt, despite new attention from the White House and Congress, is a far more pervasive problem than previously reported.
Marjorie Taylor Greene and J6 defendant Brandon Straka pray
Aug 08 2022

CPAC and Conservative Pseudo Christianity

Conservative Evangelicals are not the last faithful remnant of Christ’s Church standing firm for the Gospel in a Godless world that they claim to be—they are actively,...
In response to the Kansas vote, art from Twitter
Aug 06 2022

Women’s Rights: Kansas Voters Have Spoken

After Kansas voters defeated an anti-abortion amendment in a landslide, analysts are now sifting through that happy, massive Republican miscalculation to consider an...
Subscribe for Updates!

Subscribe for Updates!

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from our team.

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This