What Are the Possibilities of Obstruction of Justice Charges For Trump?

by | Sep 1, 2022 | Human Rights & Justice

A Department of Justice photo shows of documents seized during its Mar-a-Lago search. Department of Justice via Associated Press

What Are the Possibilities of Obstruction of Justice Charges For Trump?

by | Sep 1, 2022 | Human Rights & Justice

A Department of Justice photo shows of documents seized during its Mar-a-Lago search. Department of Justice via Associated Press
The latest revelations about Trump's stash of classified documents has prompted observers to say that obstruction of justice charges are at stake. The specific crime at issue is obstructing a federal investigation.

A court filing by the Justice Department just minutes before midnight on Aug. 30, 2022, was a sharply worded attack on former President Donald Trump’s request for a so-called “special master”—a neutral arbiter—to review the documents the FBI seized at his estate, Mar-a-Lago, earlier in the month.

Bottom line: The Justice Department says the documents don’t belong to Trump and says someone has deliberately concealed documents marked classified from a federal grand jury investigation. The department has not yet publicly stated who they believe is guilty of this crime—whether Trump himself, members of his team, or both.

In the filing, the Justice Department wrote, “The government also developed evidence that government records were likely concealed and removed from the Storage Room and that efforts were likely taken to obstruct the government’s investigation.”

This latest revelation has prompted observers to say that obstruction of justice charges are at stake. But that’s a broad term that covers many wrongful acts. The specific crime at issue here is obstructing a federal investigation.

The Conversation asked Georgia State University legal expert Clark Cunningham, an authority on search warrants, to describe the meaning of obstruction, and why Trump may be charged with this crime.

The crime of obstruction, and a particular version of it

There are 21 different federal crimes that involve obstruction of justice. One of the obstruction laws, called Section 1519, is violated if someone “knowingly conceals any document with the intent to obstruct”—or block—a federal investigation. That’s obstruction of a federal investigation, and conviction for this crime can result in up to 20 years of prison.

For example, Jesse Benton, who managed Ron Paul’s 2012 presidential campaign, was convicted of violating Section 1519 when he concealed improper campaign payments from the Federal Election Commission. Trump later pardoned Benton in December 2020.

The FBI cites Section 1519 in its Mar-a-Lago search warrant and in the recently unsealed affidavit submitted to a Florida court to obtain the warrant. But until the Department of Justice’s Aug. 30, 2022, midnight court filing, the public did not know what kind of concealment and what kind of obstruction the department was alleging Trump committed.

Pages from the FBI’s redacted search warrant affidavit for former President Donald Trump’s Mar-a-Lago estate are shown. Mario Tama/Getty Images

Why the government alleges this crime was committed at Mar-a-Lago

A federal grand jury subpoena demanded on May 11, 2022, that Trump turn over all documents with classified markings to the government.

The FBI was informed by Trump representatives in a sworn statement at Mar-a-Lago on June 3 that all documents marked classified were being turned over that day. This statement has now been proved to be false.

Trump was aware of the FBI’s June 3 visit to Mar-a-Lago. In his own court filings he has said that he personally met the FBI agents when they arrived.

Despite the sworn statement that no more documents marked as classified remained at Mar-a-Lago, the FBI found 76 documents marked classified in a storage room during its subsequent Aug. 8, 2022 search of Mar-a-Lago. They also found documents marked “Top Secret” in a container in Trump’s private office. The agents also seized a desk drawer in that office containing documents marked classified that were mixed in with other items, including Trump’s passports.

The government believes that the false statement made to the agents on June 3, as well as other evidence they have not yet disclosed, shows there was a deliberate plan to conceal documents that should have been given to the grand jury.

Before the Aug. 30 filing, it appeared that Trump’s most serious risk of criminal liability involved violating the Espionage Act by willfully retaining documents relating to national security after he left office. Revelation of these new details emphasize another offense to be added to the list of his possible crimes: obstruction of a federal investigation.The Conversation

Republished with permission from The Conversation, by Clark D. Cunningham, W. Lee Burge Chair in Law & Ethics; Director, National Institute for Teaching Ethics & Professionalism, Georgia State University

The Conversation

The Conversation

The Conversation is a nonprofit, independent news organization dedicated to unlocking the knowledge of experts for the public good. We publish trustworthy and informative articles written by academic experts for the general public and edited by our team of journalists.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Related Articles

Sep 22 2022

Time to Use 14th Amendment Against Lawmakers Who Betrayed Their Oaths on January 6

Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington argues there some current and future members of Congress should be disqualified from holding office under Section 3...
Sep 21 2022

Martha’s Vineyard Migrants Sue DeSantis

The migrants flown to Martha’s Vineyard by DeSantis had actually been pursuing legal immigration channels when they were conned into leaving their shelter. They...
Sep 18 2022

The Republican Governors Using Cruelty as a Campaign Strategy

The idea that cruelty can serve as a political tool should give us all pause. Our humanity as a nation is at stake when politicians seek support from those who view...
Sep 11 2022

Will a Texas Court Decision Against ACA Change Preventive Medical Services Costs?

A Federal judge basically said that using the Preventive Services Task Force (a nongovernmental volunteer advisory panel) recommendations to compel the offering of free...
Aug 30 2022

Deputy of Former Mesa County Clerk Tina Peters Agrees to Testify Against Her in Election Security Case

Tina Peters, a Republican who has promoted election conspiracy theories, is alleged to have facilitated a security breach in her own election office in which allowed...
Aug 29 2022

Judge Rules Bayer CEO Werner Baumann Must Give Testimony in Roundup Litigation

Baumann was instrumental in driving Bayer to buy Monsanto and has been the public face of the company’s continued insistence that Monsanto’s Roundup, and other...
Dani Yuengling of Conway, South Carolina, researched how much a needle biopsy of a lump in her breast might cost. The hospital website showed it would be about $1,400 for someone without insurance. She reasoned her bill with insurance would be less. Instead, the sticker price was close to $18,000, and she was on the hook for more than $5,000 — the balance of her deductible. (Gavin McIntyre for KHN)
Aug 25 2022

Medical Overbilling: The $18,000 Breast Biopsy

Dani Yuengling researched how much a needle biopsy of a lump in her breast might cost. The hospital website showed it would be about $1,400 for someone without...
Ugandans watch the start of the International Criminal Court trial of former child soldier-turned-warlord Dominic Ongwen. Isaac Kasamani/AFP via Getty Images
Aug 24 2022

A Sobering Analysis of the Connections Between Slavery and War

An analysis of the frequency of enslavement in armed conflicts paints a disturbing picture. Most conflicts involving enslavement take place in low-income countries,...
Aug 23 2022

John Fetterman Calls for Prosecution of Price Gouging Corporate Executives

“It’s time we crack down on the big, price gouging corporations that are making record profits while jacking up prices for all of us,” said John Fetterman,...
Aug 19 2022

Why Are Republicans Now Turning Against the League of Women Voters?

The League of Women Voters, long known for focusing on voter registration and other fundamentals, became more willing to speak boldly during the Trump era. Now, some on...
Subscribe for Updates!

Subscribe for Updates!

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from our team.

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This